Category: Pondering Peace
Greed, Wealth, and Gratitude
Jesus once told a story that has been aptly entitled “The Parable of the Rich Fool.” He prefaced it by saying, “Take care! Be on your guard against all kinds of greed; for one’s life does not consist in the abundance of possessions” (Luke 12:15, NRSV). The story goes like this.
There was a rich man whose land produced abundantly. Realizing that he did not have enough room to store it all, he wondered what to do. Then he thought to himself, “I will pull down my barns and build larger ones, and there I will store all my grain and my goods. And I will say to my soul, ‘Soul, you have ample goods laid up for many years; relax, eat, drink, be merry’” (vv. 18-19).
It sounds a bit like he has attained the American dream – a successful business and wealth that he uses on himself so that he can relax, perhaps retire early, eat good food, and enjoy life. Immersed in our American culture, we may find it hard to see what is wrong with this. However, God’s disapproval is expressed with the words, “You fool! This very night your life is being demanded of you. And the things you have prepared, whose will they be?” (v. 20)
Jesus was apparently depicting this man as an example of greed. Notice how often the word my appears in his ruminations. He is thinking of no one else except himself. He regarded what the land produced as all his, to be spent solely on his own comfort and enjoyment. There is no mention of the workers, who likely were exploited with low wages to do the hard labor of growing the crops. There is no thought of sharing the wealth they helped to produce with them so they also can enjoy life a little more and have what they need.
The Bible has some mixed messages about wealth. Sometimes it is seen as a blessing from God or attained through hard work. Other times it is viewed as resulting from the oppression of others through seizing land and exploiting workers. Within the oppressive context of his day, when religious leaders were collaborating with Roman occupiers to tax the people into poverty while they themselves financially benefited, Jesus clearly came out on the side of the poor and warned about the dangers of wealth. Luke records Jesus saying this rather starkly, “Blessed are you who are poor…But woe to you who are rich…” (Luke 6:20-25).
Those with wealth were welcome to become Jesus’ followers, but they then shared their wealth as a community resource. Zacchaeus gave half of his wealth to the poor and reimbursed four-fold whatever excessive amount he had taken while collecting taxes (Luke 19:8). Women followers with some means shared what they had to support Jesus’ ministry (Luke 8:1-3). But for others, their wealth was an obstacle to following Jesus, as it was for the rich man in Mark 10:21-22. A focus on the accumulation of wealth too often keeps one from fully embracing the radical discipleship to which Jesus calls us. Jesus stated this clearly, “You cannot serve God and wealth” (Matthew 6:24).
The New Testament writers who followed Jesus continued this perspective. They cautioned that the one who is greedy has no inheritance in the Kingdom of God and equated greed with idolatry (Ephesians 5:5). They warned about false teachers who “in their greed will exploit you with deceptive words” (2 Peter 2:3). They admonished that “those who want to be rich fall into temptation and are trapped… For the love of money is a root to all kinds of evil” (I Timothy 6:9-10). The early Church listed greed as one of the seven deadly sins.
Instead of greed and seeking after wealth, Jesus and early Christian writers encouraged a simple lifestyle, contentment, generosity, and gratitude. “There is great gain in godliness combined with contentment… if we have food and clothing, we will be content with these” (1 Timothy 6:6,8). Paul told the Philippines that he had learned to be content with whatever he had (4:11) while urging them to let God know of their needs, but always with thanksgiving (4:6). If one had wealth, it was to be shared with those in need, as was demonstrated among Jesus’ followers in the early Jerusalem church (Acts 4:32-35). This Thanksgiving season is an opportunity for us to commit ourselves to living this way of life. Greed gobbles up gratitude, while contentment, simplicity, and generosity nurture it.
But there is more we can learn from the parable of the rich fool. The actions exemplified by the rich fool seem quite consistent with our current economic system of capitalism. On the other hand, Jesus’ parable about the wealthy landowner who gave a day laborer’s wages to each one who worked for him, regardless of how many hours they worked, seems unfair and almost inexplicable from the perspective of our capitalist system. Yet Jesus speaks approvingly of the landowner who used his wealth to make sure everyone received enough wages to feed their families that night, even those who had not found this job opportunity until late in the day. This approach provided for the basic needs of all at the cost of the wealthy man thinking of others and being willing to give up some of his wealth (Matthew 20:1-15).
Many equate capitalism with the American way of life. Some go even further to assume it is the economic system most compatible with Christianity. Many point out the positive aspects of capitalism, in that it rewards innovation, fosters economic growth, and creates significant wealth. But since the 1980s and the Reagan era, a globalized capitalism that is increasingly unregulated has become dominant. And with this, major problems have emerged. Capitalism brings great wealth, but only to a few, and the gap between the rich and poor is growing ever larger. With a priority on short term financial gains and increasing profits for shareholders, workers and the earth itself are viewed as simply to be used, and too often are exploited. Its reliance on ever increasing consumption for economic growth is unsustainable within the limits of the earth’s resources. Fossil fuels have been used recklessly without consideration to the damage they have on the environment and atmosphere. In fact, in Love in a Time of Climate Change, Sharon Delgado asserts that climate change represents “a profound failure of free-market capitalism” (168).
In addition, as a few men have become increasingly wealthy, they also have become more politically powerful in influencing legislators to pass laws and policies for their benefit. This increased power held by a small number of the very wealthy is a threat to democracy. Whereas there is some disagreement as to whether greed is an essential part of the capitalist system, the presence of corporate greed, especially on the part of extravagantly paid CEOs of large corporations, is difficult to dispute.
Christian theologians and leaders are increasingly concerned about this issue. Pastor and public theologian Sharon Delgado writes, “When the values of unrestrained free-market capitalism dominate public policy, economic relationships take priority, and the social fabric is torn apart. When the market is the primary measurement of value, those without money are left behind. This is idolatry that places money at the pinnacle of values and relationships and discounts human, social, and environmental needs. We need a public discussion of values that go beyond profit and self-interest, and a change of policies leading to a transformed economy and world” (171-172). In her book Building a Moral Economy, Lutheran theologian and social ethicist Cynthia Moe-Lobeda calls for a life-giving economy that is more equitable, ecological, and democratic than the one we have now.
As Christians we need to take a hard look at the economic system in which we live and then work for one that is more just and sustainable. We cannot just assume that unregulated free-market capitalism, especially the global capitalism of today, is the best economic system. We can learn about other options. Many younger people are embracing democratic socialism, including some being elected to office. This expresses their recognition that something else is needed besides the exploitative capitalism we are currently caught in. Those who embrace this approach express a desire for resources to be more equitably shared so that everyone will have their basic needs met. They carry a commitment to put the welfare of people over the profits of corporations.
It could be that a better name for the economic system they want is “social democracy.” This is a form of democracy that leverages capitalism to benefit people. The means of production are privately owned, but they are heavily regulated and taxed to ensure that all citizens have an adequate standard of living. Versions of this economic system are utilized by the Scandinavian countries, which have strong safety nets and far less disparity between the rich and poor. Year after year, their citizens express high levels of happiness.
This Thanksgiving, as we give thanks for the gifts of the earth and all the other blessings we enjoy, we are invited to embrace personal practices of simplicity, contentment, generosity, and gratitude. In this way, we will move away from patterns of overconsumption in our love for others and the earth. Along with this, we are encouraged to commit ourselves to advocacy for economic policies that are more just and sustainable so that all people, all living things, and the earth itself will flourish.
Rev. Ruth Rosell, Ph.D.
Director of the Buttry Center for Peace and Nonviolence
Associate Professor of Pastoral Theology Emerita
Central Seminary, Overland Park, KS
The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author.
Photo by Brigitte Elsner on Unsplash